So I planted an American Sycamore 4 years ago when it was about 2’ tall (photos include a picture at this height). Over time and as the tree grew in diameter, the bark began to develop cracks and fall off. After some research I believe I diagnosed it to ice possibly freezing and cracking the bark in the wintertime (correct me if you have differing beliefs). But besides the cracking at the lower 2’ of trunk, the tree continues to grow new, healthy-looking leaves and has no bark issues above that point. I’ve included photos of the cracking and bark issues that surround the tree trunk. Will this tree make it? Or should I replace it now when it has a chance? I feel bad cutting it down, especially since I grew it from such a small tree and invested time in caring for it. What does everyone think?
by Accomplished_Exam399
4 Comments
If it’s continuing to grow a healthy canopy I would say just watch it. If you see die back or further cracking then I would say consider taking it down. They are a hardy species so I would assume it will be fine.
Is the damage facing southwest? Either way, I believe this advice is relevant.
“White tree guards may help prevent this from occurring due to the reflection of the sun, preventing overheating on the bottom of the trunk. In order to prevent cracking, try to prevent any type of mechanical damage that could cause cracking in the winter. Bark cracks become visible most often during the late winter/early spring. In some circumstances a healthy plant may heal, partitioning off the damaged area, but the bark on a plant under stress, due to drought, herbicide damage, etc., may last the entire life of the tree.” Kyle Daniel, Southwest Injury of Trees, Purdue University Extension
It looks like years of string trimmer damage to me. Is anyone using a string trimmer against the trunk of the tree?
Need banana for scale